What if?
Everyone knows at the end of Return of the Jedi, Luke fulfills his destiny as he symbolically denies the Emperor one last time and proclaims himself saying “I am a Jedi, like my father before me.”
But what would have happened if Luke succumbed to his emotions and struck the final blow to kill Vader?
Would he then go on to pledge himself to the Emperor or try to engage the Dark Lord in conflict as well?
First off, it’s important to understand this…Luke, much like his father, heavily relied on the advice from his role models.
Anakin had Chancellor Palpatine fill that void, that didn’t go so well for him but for Luke it might have been different.
As for Luke, he had old Ben Kenobi. A force in his life that would remain a major stalwart so much so that he would go on to name one of his sons Ben.
However, in this moment, Ben was not with him. Therefore leaving Luke dangerously open to seduction.
So, imagine Luke is standing over Vader’s lifeless corpse when the Emperor moseys on over.
Someone like Luke who would realize the gravity of the situation would almost immediately would look for guidance.
I’d imagine that the Emperor, using his crafty and grandfatherly advice would attempt to brainwash Luke to the point of no return. Yes, that’s right, to the Dark Side.
Now time to go back to the original question. Would Luke turn on Sidious in this moment? Maybe after he realized that it might be the only way to turn a heinous situation into a pertinent one and still remain one of the good guys.
I’d have to say, yes he probably would.
Of course in the movie, after he defeats Vader, Luke sees the flaws in his aggressive actions and tosses away his weapon and acknowledges his fate.
So for arguments sake, lets say Luke engaged the Emperor.
Luke vs Sidious
When the Emperor first lays eyes on Luke, there is a sense of trepidation and fear that even Luke feels emanating from the Dark Lord.
Not that this would have really mattered but nonetheless, the Emperor was afraid of Luke and saw him as a threat.
With this being said, I find it hard to believe that Luke would really stand a chance. After all, he’s completely decimated from the Emperor’s force lightning.
Plus, with the Emperor already feeling threatened and a tinge of fear, I’m sure he’d release his full arsenal of power.
Luke’s Jedi upbringing was incomplete and fragmented since both of his teachers died/killed at some point during his teachings.
With this being said, as you saw in the ROTJ, Luke would have been obliterated by the Emperor’s lightning.
He simply did not have the necessary training to comprehend how to counter the Emperor’s crackling electric energy spewing from his finger tips.
With his father now no more and the Emperor’s complete lack of mercy, Luke would be a goner.
You also have to understand this. The fact that the Emperor would need another enforcer since Vader has departed, I could very much see the Emperor end his electrical barrage at the last second and force Luke to swear his loyalty.
Of course he’d probably allow his darkness to handicap Luke in someway (similar to what happened to Anakin) in order for Sidious to feel more comfortable around a force like Luke.
Now it would remain to be seen if Luke would pledge himself (I doubt it) but nevertheless that’s how things would most likely play out.
Luke Wins
Consider the fact that the Emperor in his old age is practically ancient and by the look of his face alone, he looks prehistoric!
What would have happened if Luke got up close to the Sith Lord? Right there would be a turning point.
Not in ROTJ, but in the expanded universe, the emperor has said it himself. He considers lightsaber combat primitive and barbaric, something he likes to boast saying it’s a Jedi action.
The Emperor believes in conflict through the force.
Now what happens if Luke was able to incapacitate Sidous from using his force abilities?
I very much doubt that the Emperor carries around a lightsaber of his own anymore and I bet he’d be weaker than ever with it as well.
There is something to be said of his ability to augment his physicality and possibly raise his competitive edge up higher through exposing himself to the force.
Still, I don’t think he would be able to match Luke’s prowess. I mean, just look at Luke. He’s a physical specimen just like his father was.
Luke’s Next Move
Now that Luke has eliminated the heads of the Empire, what would his next move be?
He could easily just exit the Death Star and return to his friends. However, he could just as easily assume control of Imperial operations and follow a similar path that Anakin did.
I tend to think Luke would do the latter.
He even realizes himself that he had a strange fascination and enjoyed the power of the Dark Side as it surged through him and around him as he stands over his father.
Luke is an emotional person. It’s only up until he enters Jabba’s Palace does he begin to take charge of his emotions.
The key is, his emotional outbursts are still there, just guarded.
Of course it’s toned down compared to his bout with Vader in The Empire Strikes Back but it does remain in his character.
End Game
If Luke did end up joining the Dark Side, it signals ultimate doom for the Rebellion and future Jedi hope.
Luke would go on to be possibly the most powerful, dynamic and unopposed Sith Lord the galaxy had ever seen.
Reason being, all the Jedi competition would practically be eliminated and extinct!
That’s one way to remain at the top!
It’s plausible to say, Leia could still sway Luke or maybe Luke could even sway Leia.
Still, I can’t see Leia turning and abandoning her cause. She’s just too invested. Plus the Empire did kill her adopted parents so that’s a big hurdle to get over as well…
Leia just seems to stubborn and set in her ways compared to Luke but hey, ya never know!
One thing is for sure, it would be a dark dark day if Luke ever turned to the Sith.
-Sith Pacify out